What is the difference between PCB FR4 and FR2?

Introduction to PCB Materials

Printed circuit boards (PCBs) are essential components in modern electronic devices, providing a platform for mounting and connecting electronic components. The choice of PCB material is crucial as it affects the board’s performance, durability, and cost. Two commonly used PCB materials are FR4 and FR2. In this article, we will explore the differences between PCB FR4 and FR2, their properties, applications, and factors to consider when choosing between them.

Request PCB Manufacturing & Assembly Quote Now

What is FR4?

FR4 (Flame Retardant 4) is a composite material made from woven fiberglass cloth impregnated with an epoxy resin binder. It is the most widely used PCB material due to its excellent mechanical, electrical, and thermal properties. FR4 is known for its high strength, good insulation properties, and resistance to moisture and chemicals.

Properties of FR4

High mechanical strength and stiffness
Excellent electrical insulation properties
Good thermal stability and flame retardance
Low water absorption and high moisture resistance
Suitable for high-frequency applications
Wide operating temperature range (-40°C to +130°C)

Applications of FR4

FR4 PCBs are used in a wide range of applications, including:

Consumer electronics (smartphones, laptops, tablets)
Industrial control systems
Automotive electronics
Medical devices
Telecommunications equipment
Aerospace and defense systems

What is FR2?

FR2 (Flame Retardant 2), also known as phenolic paper or phenolic cotton paper, is a composite material made from cellulose paper impregnated with a phenolic resin binder. FR2 is an older PCB material that was widely used before the introduction of FR4. It is still used in some applications due to its lower cost and specific properties.

Properties of FR2

Lower cost compared to FR4
Good electrical insulation properties
Adequate mechanical strength for low-stress applications
Higher water absorption compared to FR4
Limited thermal stability and lower operating temperature range
Not suitable for high-frequency applications

Applications of FR2

FR2 PCBs are used in applications where cost is a primary concern and the performance requirements are less demanding:

Low-end consumer electronics
Single-sided PCBs for simple circuits
Educational and hobby projects
Low-power and low-frequency applications

PCB FR4 vs FR2: Key Differences

Now that we have a basic understanding of FR4 and FR2, let’s compare their key differences in a table format:

Property	FR4	FR2
Base Material	Woven fiberglass	Cellulose paper
Resin Binder	Epoxy	Phenolic
Mechanical Strength	High	Moderate
Electrical Insulation	Excellent	Good
Thermal Stability	High	Limited
Moisture Resistance	High	Moderate
Water Absorption	Low	High
Frequency Suitability	High	Low
Operating Temperature Range	-40°C to +130°C	Limited
Cost	Higher	Lower

1. Mechanical Properties

FR4 has superior mechanical properties compared to FR2. FR4 PCBs are stronger, stiffer, and more durable, making them suitable for applications that require high reliability and resistance to mechanical stress. FR2 PCBs, on the other hand, have lower mechanical strength and are more prone to warping and bending.

2. Electrical Properties

Both FR4 and FR2 have good electrical insulation properties. However, FR4 has a slight advantage in terms of dielectric constant and dissipation factor, making it more suitable for high-frequency applications. FR2 PCBs are limited to low-frequency applications due to their higher dielectric losses.

3. Thermal Properties

FR4 has better thermal stability and a wider operating temperature range compared to FR2. FR4 PCBs can withstand temperatures from -40°C to +130°C, while FR2 PCBs have a more limited temperature range. FR4 also has better heat dissipation properties, which is essential for high-power applications.

4. Moisture Resistance

FR4 has higher moisture resistance and lower water absorption compared to FR2. This makes FR4 PCBs more suitable for applications exposed to humid environments or requiring long-term reliability. FR2 PCBs are more susceptible to moisture absorption, which can lead to dimensional changes and degradation of electrical properties over time.

5. Cost

FR2 PCBs are generally cheaper than FR4 PCBs due to the lower cost of raw materials and simpler manufacturing processes. However, the cost difference has diminished over time as FR4 has become more widely adopted and production volumes have increased.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between FR4 and FR2

When deciding between FR4 and FR2 for your PCB project, consider the following factors:

Application requirements: Evaluate the mechanical, electrical, and thermal requirements of your application to determine which material is more suitable.
Operating environment: Consider the environmental conditions your PCB will be exposed to, such as temperature, humidity, and chemical exposure.
Frequency and power: Determine the frequency range and power levels of your application. FR4 is better suited for high-frequency and high-power applications.
Cost and budget: Consider the cost implications of using FR4 or FR2, taking into account the overall project budget and production volume.
Manufacturability: Assess the manufacturability of your PCB design with each material, considering factors such as minimum feature sizes, layer count, and surface finish requirements.

Conclusion

In conclusion, FR4 and FR2 are two commonly used PCB materials with distinct properties and applications. FR4 is the more advanced and widely adopted material, offering superior mechanical, electrical, and thermal properties. It is suitable for a wide range of applications, including high-frequency and high-reliability systems. FR2, on the other hand, is an older material that is still used in low-cost and low-performance applications where its limitations are acceptable.

When choosing between FR4 and FR2, it is essential to carefully consider the specific requirements of your application, operating environment, frequency range, power levels, cost, and manufacturability. By understanding the differences between these two materials and evaluating your project needs, you can make an informed decision and select the most appropriate PCB material for your application.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can FR2 PCBs be used for multilayer designs?

While FR2 PCBs can be used for multilayer designs, they are typically limited to a maximum of 2 or 4 layers due to their lower mechanical strength and higher water absorption compared to FR4. FR4 is the preferred choice for complex multilayer designs.

2. Is it possible to mix FR4 and FR2 materials in the same PCB?

Mixing FR4 and FR2 materials in the same PCB is not recommended due to their different mechanical and thermal properties. This can lead to reliability issues and manufacturing challenges. It is best to choose one material that meets the overall requirements of your application.

3. How do FR4 and FR2 compare in terms of signal integrity?

FR4 has better signal integrity properties compared to FR2, particularly at higher frequencies. FR4 has a lower dielectric constant and dissipation factor, which results in lower signal loss and distortion. FR2 is more suitable for low-frequency applications where signal integrity is less critical.

4. Are there any environmental concerns with using FR4 or FR2?

Both FR4 and FR2 contain flame retardants to improve their fire resistance. Some older flame retardants, such as polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) and polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), have been identified as persistent organic pollutants and are being phased out. Modern FR4 and FR2 materials use safer and more environmentally friendly flame retardants.

5. Can FR4 and FR2 PCBs be recycled?

Recycling FR4 and FR2 PCBs can be challenging due to the complex mixture of materials used in their construction. However, there are specialized recycling facilities that can process PCBs to recover valuable metals and materials. It is essential to properly dispose of PCBs through authorized recycling channels to minimize environmental impact and ensure responsible resource management.